Emperor’s New Clothes? – The Song of Achilles by Madeline Miller

achillesI was really looking forward to reading The Song of Achilles. It has sold well and is highly regarded, even winning the Orange Prize in 2012. One of my favourite books of 2013 was Tim Leach’s excellent Last King of Lydia – a retelling of Herodotus, that informs and reflects modern day political and social discourse. I was expecting much the same from Achilles, such was the acclaim. Leach’s book hasn’t won any prizes, and I don’t imagine it’s sold by the bucketload from supermarkets, but it is by far the better book.

Perhaps I have been victim of my own expectations (a problem I have often written about), but I found the Song of Achilles little more than ordinary. Having grown up on a diet of swords and sandals (admittedly more often with wizards), I feel the book offered little more than your average genre fare. Manfredi and Gemmell have delivered equally interesting reads set in similar circumstances. Being a retelling of Homer, obviously the story is sound, but whereas Leach’s Lydia is multi-layered and thought provoking, Miller’s Achilles is a simple, flat retelling.

There is nothing wrong with the book. It gets you from A to B via violent filicide. Yes, there’s a wonderful loving relationship in trying circumstances, there’s a tragic ending, there’s pride (so much pride) and there’s a fall (well many falls), but I didn’t find any of it more remarkable than anything I’ve read before. It’s well written, but bar a few of the more colourful details, it could be a retelling for 11 year olds. I guess, it seems a bit churlish to bemoan a book for doing little more than telling a good story, but seeing as it’s not an original story, and it won a prestigious prize, I feel justified in expecting a little more.



3 thoughts on “Emperor’s New Clothes? – The Song of Achilles by Madeline Miller

  1. I was interested in this at one point, but a few folks I trust gave me a heads up that it’s got too much romance for my tastes, lol.

  2. Sorry it didn’t meet your expectations. I had the opposite reaction that it exceeded my expectations, taking me to unexpected places — in terms of the relationships.

    1. I Like the relationship between Petroclus and Briseis, but the rest I found largely derivative. But lots of other people have taken far more from this book than me, so perhaps I missed something.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s